Yesterday, I had to write the exam questions for my students of Soil Science in the Faculty of Biology. As they are very more than 300, because of the facilities that my government gives to the fulfillment of the Bologna Process and the European Higher Education Area (ironic mode activated), I usually make multiple choice tests (if you do the same, have a look at this). However, I like to put some questions to see if students are able to solve problems, rather than selecting the correct answer from a number of possibilities.
To achieve this, one of the things I do is to display a picture and ask the student to give me all the information that can be extracted. For example, if I show a soil profile, I ask the student to say, only from the soil profile in the image, the geographical location, the type of climate, land use, geomorphological description of the area, etc.
So, for this case, I decided not to use a picture from my collection, but go into Wikipedia and seek for any image useful for my purpose. I typed “suelo” (soil, in Spanish) in the Spanish edition of Wikipedia and this is how one of the most funny times I’ve spent reading since I read “Lazarillo de Tormes” started. I hope someone has corrected the Spanish Wikipedia Suelo entry after December 11th 2013 (not me).
I found statements such as the following:
- In a simple way, it can be said that the steps involved in the formation of soil are: “mechanical disintegration of rocks and chemical weathering of regolitic materials, (comma) released“. And that’s all, folks. No more stages in soil evolution.
- “On colluvium materials, that thing commonly referred to as soil may develop“. That’s it, just on colluvium. And this is that thing commonly referred to as scientific language.
- According to its function (?), soils can be “sandy, calcareous, humiferous, clayey, rocky and mixed“. In the case of clayey soils, these: “are formed by fine yellowish grains and retain water in ponds“. This guy has managed to see the color of clay particles!
- Calcareous soils are white. What about terra rossa?
- According to their physical characteristics, soil groups are: Litosols, Cambisols, Luvisols, Acrisols, Gleysols, Fluvisols, Rendzinas and Vertisols. No more soil types according to their physical characteristics. My students are infinitely grateful.
- There are detailed reviews of each case. Rendzinas, for example, are soils with “a horizon of about 50 cm deep“. Are you sure? More: Fluvisols are rich in calcium and Lithosols are soils that appear on rocky outcrops.
After this, a chapter is devoted to the classification of soils. According to Spanish Wikipedia:
- “Soils can be classified according to their texture: fine or coarse“. Have you heard about “silty clay loam soils”? Not me, the Super-Wikipedist.
- Poorly developed soils are: “polar soils, deserts (rock and sand) and beaches“, and there are three types: Rankers, Rendzinas and steppe soils. Please, tell me: assuming that a beach is a soil, where are beaches included?
- Among the wide variety of “developed soils“, there are soils of temperate forests, rainy regions, temperate climates (I guess these do not include temperate forests) and the Mediterranean red soil. Hey, hey, hey… they were not white?. But do not worry, because “if the weather is suitable and the place is accessible, most of these areas are now occupied by farms“.
- One of the most important soil problems is “soil destruction“. According to Spanish Wikipedia, “very serious data claim that trees will be extinguished in twelve or thirteen years, and we will need to import all the wood“. This is frightening. Where will we import wood from? From Endor?
- More. Due to excessive sedimentation, we will end up with… navigable rivers! That’s the key issue, world!
After this, and discovering that the O horizon is the surface layer of A, the A horizon is a washed horizon and the C horizon is the subsoil “fragmented by mechanical and chemical action (but the chemical weathering does not exist)“, the reader finds a chapter about Soil Classification (yes, again, this is the third one in the same page). Here, you can read things like:
- “There are three main soil models, namely: the Podzol, the Chernozem and the latosol“.
Dear students: I hope this will serve to understand the difference between internet and books. Next time we will talk about Google Translator.
This post was also published simultaneously in the EGU Blog Network.